The Greatest ROBIN Outfit That Never Was

A Don Newton birthday salute …


UPDATED 11/12/23: The late fan-fave artist Don Newton was born 89 years ago. His Detective Comics #526 — with Jason Todd’s original costume — remains a high-water mark in his career, so it’s the perfect time to “reprint” this piece from 2015’s ROBIN WEEK. Oh, and click here for a more in-depth look at that glorious cover itself. — Dan



In the early ’80s, you could get through life as a comic-book fan without spoilers pretty simply. You’d hear rumors and maybe somebody at your shop (if you had one) knew someone who knew someone, or at least that’s what they’d say.

There were the listings for upcoming comics in the back of the books and fan magazines and company newsletters, but really, nothing immediate.

So as a 16-year-old in 1983, I can be forgiven for patting myself on the back for figuring out that this red-headed circus kid named Jason Todd was going to be a new Robin.

I’m certain there was info in the zeitgeist about Dick becoming Nightwing, but my memory is unclear on the details of that. I do remember finding out the name through a Direct Currents newsletter sent to dealers.


Anyway, I just remember opening up Detective #526 and seeing this pic and thinking: “I called it!” or the early-’80s equivalent. (Hey, forgive the youthful boasting. Everything’s obvious in retrospect.)


Don Newton pencils. Alfredo Alcala inks. Adrienne Roy colors. Written by Gerry Conway.

What wasn’t clear was whether this was going to be a permanent thing. And they even toyed with fans for some time about whether Jason was going to have a different superhero identity.

But, man, I loved that outfit. I used to sketch it, especially that collar area. If there was going to be a new Robin, it was great that he was going to get his own outfit — especially one with pants.

See, the pants thing was a big deal at the time. (The other day I wrote a piece about all of Dick Grayson’s Bronze Age costume possibilities. It’s fun. If you’re reading this I think you’ll like it. Click here.)

Detective #481. Also Don Newton (w/Dan Adkins).

Detective #481. Also Don Newton (w/Dan Adkins).

Alas, it was not to be. Sure, Jason became Robin. But DC was not primed to change his basic, merchandisable look — at least not until some years later.

They even made him dye his hair. I mean if Bruce Wayne takes in another boy, and he’s got red hair, and then Batman shows up with a new kid the same age with red hair, well… (After Crisis on Infinite Earths, Jason was naturally black-haired.)

But nothing changes the fact that this outfit was great. Yes, Jason, it looks terrific.


— It’s ROBIN WEEK! Click here.

— 13 COVERS of Robin in the Golden Age. Click here.

— 13 COVERS of Robin in the Silver Age. Click here.

— 13 COVERS of Robin in the Bronze Age. Click here.

— Robin, the Teen Fashionista: Dick Grayson’s Bronze Age costume choices. Click here.

Author: Dan Greenfield

Share This Post On


  1. Yeah, I saw some of those costumes. This does look pretty cool. I guess Dick was Robin so long, I just didn’t take to Jason. I like the new, long pants costume; and, Alex Ross’ Red Robin design.

    Post a Reply
  2. This costume was simply something that artist Don Newton drew up as a possible costume design. Of note were his desire to cover up Robin’s legs, and to bring some “carnival gymnast” look to the costume. I was there when Don drew this drawing.

    Post a Reply
  3. If they’d given Jason that costume, and let him keep his strawberry blonde hair, he may have had an identity distinct enough to catch on with fans and not look like a cipher for Dick Grayson. Then they wouldn’t have had to recast him into the unlikable creep he became Post-Crisis.

    I LOVE that costume! Slap an “R” on his belt-buckle and call it a day.

    Post a Reply
    • I agree 100% with you Stephen. I also like the adult Robin with BATMAN elements. There was nothing I liked about (any) new Robins.

      Post a Reply
  4. I still LOVE this design. It’s a big favorite of my son’s too. DC really missed a beat not keeping it around.

    Post a Reply
  5. Bring back Jason 1.0!!! Stuck in limbo foreverrrrrrrrrrrr!!!!

    Post a Reply


  1. BATMAN FAMILY: The Coolest Batbook of the Bronze Age | 13th Dimension, Comics, Creators, Culture - […] 11/7/17: I’ve been thinking about Batman Family again lately. This piece about Jason Todd’s first costume had something tangentially…
  2. ROBIN, the Teen Fashionista | 13th Dimension, Comics, Creators, Culture - […] BONUS:The Greatest Robin Costume That Never Was. Click here. […]

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: